Make Matt get Kara a towel
From Create Your Own Story
You look at Matt and shrug your head signaling him to get a towel for Kara, Matt then walks towards what he thinks is the nearest bathroom, you know enough Matt will take a while and decide to use this chance to pop Kara’s cherry. Having her eyes closed and face covered in jizz she would never know who took her virginity, and slowly walk behind Kara, Kara then says to herself, “I wonder if both of them left me just to find me a towel”. And you push her back and she says “woah” getting her on all fours and say “so one of you guys are here, is it (Your Name) with a giggly tone, or you Matt with a flat tone voice”. Hearing her say your name with a better tone then Matt you smile and rub the tip of your cock between her moist virgin pussy lips, and she releases a little moan and says that’s feels good and you start rubbing her lips a little faster and get her to increase the volume of her moans.
Once she starts to breath heavlier then normal you shove your erect dick into her tight pussy , she releases a loud “Woah” and say “not so hard big boy I’m a virgin remember at least make my first time gentle before you fuck me like one of your whores”. Just as you pull your dick out to break her hymen Matt enters the room and notices that you and Kara are going at it and gives you one of the towels in case she’s a bleeder, and covers her face with the other and say “Dude” your late I couldn’t help myself. Kara then says “Matt are you fucking me , and he says maybe but you will never know for sure right dude” and hi fives you as you fucking Kara’s pussy. With Kara being blindfolded and you fucking her you whisper in her ear, opened that sweet mouth of yours and Matt shoves his dick in her mouth and she starts sucking it, you love fucking Kara and you want her to remember your dick being her first before Matt has his chance
After fucking for a while you start to feel like your about to cum and you want to fuck Kara pussy a second time at a harder pace, another reasons why you like fucking virgins they usually surpised that once you come you would naturally pull out only to find out that your still in them giving them another load of jizz. Forgetting you’re a football player with high stamia and a reputation of making you more then they can handle. Just then both you and Matt cum in Kara, and Matt looks at you with a stare say “we switch and you shake your head saying no not yet” while fucking Kara like you didn’t cum.
Matt then says “Kara how’s my dick feeling?”
“So fucking good Matt” she says heavily breathing, “so good, at first I was in pain but after a while it started to feel good so fuck me like one of your whores”, Upon hearing that your increase your pace and she starts increase her moans and then start to get hard and louder Matt then puts his dick in her mouth to shut her up. Not wanting to wake up her brother or parents and says “good thinking man after I release this load let’s fuck her in her room then you can go crazy ok Kara.
She knods yes with his dick in her mouth you continue fucking her hard and release another huge load into her pussy. Matt pulls his dick out of her mouth and she collapse on the floor and feels her way to the couch just then you sit next to her on the size where she thought she was sucking your dick and say “Are you alright Kara, is it too much for you do you need help going upstairs or should we call it a night, Kara removes the towel from her face and says “Let’s continue this party in my room boys, but I’m a little tried out can one of you boys carry me up the stairs?”
Do you:
