Sure you carry Kara up the stairs, and Matt picks up the clothes
From Create Your Own Story
You get up in front of Kara and pick her up, Kara wraps her arms around your neck for support and you signal to Matt to pick up the clothes and meet up in her room. While Matt is picking up the clothes, you decide to grab some beers for you and Matt -- in case dehydration is a factor. As soon as you're halfway up the stairs, you hear Matt following you into Kara's room.
Once inside Kara's room, you drop Kara on her bed and Matt locks her door. Kara gets up and opens a beer and takes a couple of gulps. She looks at both of you with a horny look in her eyes.
"Alright boys, who's first?"
You look at each other.
"Let me have a go at that pussy," Matt says. But Kara stops him.
"Well that isn't very fair Matt...." She looks at you. "Our friend here still hasn't had a turn. And if I recall correctly, you already took my little pussy's virginity."
You look at Matt and nod.
"Yeah man, I know she may be a great fuck, but you're being fucking selfish."
Matt looks at you with a glimmer of hate in his eyes.
"Fine dude, go at it."
You smile with satisfaction because your earlier stunt paid off. You walk toward the sexy redhead. Kara puts the beer on her nightstand. She licks her lips and opens her pussy lips as a warm welcome. You shove your huge dick into her, roughly holding her hands above her head. She groans as you fuck her at a steady pace. You thrust into her powerfully, causing Kara to close her eyes and moan out loud.
"So how's her pussy, man?" Matt asks.
"I can see why you wanted to keep fucking her, man. She's still tight and fucking wet from before."
You and Matt high five each other.
"Tonight's mission, dude," Matt announces in his douchiest voice, "Is to make this once-tight, sweet little virgin into a used-up, cum-filled whore." The two of you laugh as you speed up, fucking Kara even harder. Her moans increase until she's screaming and orgasming on your slamming prick. At long last, you blast a huge load into her cunt.
You take your dripping dick out and Kara reaches for her beer.
"Damn. Sorry, Matt... But now I know why all the girls say that once you're with The Horse, no other guy comes close..."
You smile because not only did Kara bruise Matt's ego, but you know what all the girls at school have been saying about you. Matt looks pretty fucking pissed.
"Oh, yeah, bitch? Is that really what the girls say? I don't fucking match up with this loser?"
Matt forces Kara's body down against the mattress and shoves his thick cock deep in her pussy. The full weight of Matt's big, muscled jock body is on top of her, and he starts fucking her like an animal -- he doesn't care about hurting her or making her feel good. It's all about his pleasure. He's thrusting hard, but it looks like Kara is kind of used to it, thanks to you. You grab another beer and take a gulp, just watching Matt rail Kara.
After you finish drinking your beer, Matt cums a load into Kara's cunt.
"How was that," he pants, out of breath.
"Not bad, stud, but you could learn a few moves from your buddy over there..."
You burst out laughing.
"Sorry Matt, but my moves aren't for sale."
Kara grabs your beer and takes a sip. She looks over at you with a naughty glint in her eye.
"Maybe you should let me be on top to show you how's it's done?"
Matt, still rock hard, readily agrees. Kara gets on top of him and positions herself on top of him. She moves up and down on him, her ass bouncing up and down with wild abandon. You put your beer on her nightstand and get behind Kara, grabbing her titties and pinching her nipples. The younger girl moans and leans back, kissing you while she rides your buddy. Matt reaches up to play with Kara's breasts, both your hands now fondling the perfect orbs. As Kara leans down to kiss Matt, you see this as the perfect chance to get your dick into her ass. You grab your cock and slowly force it into her virgin asshole. Kara's eyes widen as you push your massive prick into her vice-like anal orifice. She breaks the kiss, to stop you but make puts her hands above his shoulders, making Kara straining to take both of you at once. The intensity, the pleasure, the pain is too much for her. She screams in wild abandon. You and Matt double stuff the petite teen, your buffed-up jock bodies trapping her between the two of you. For the next half hour, you fuck her until you both blow a load into her virgin ass and once-virgin pussy.
Do you and Matt:
