Don't believe Joe and break his other arm
From Create Your Own Story
"I was an actress," you say. "I know when people are telling the truth and when they're lying. And I think you're lying about Ben being your partner in crime. So now, I'm going to break your other arm." In a lightning move, you grab Joe's good arm and apply your martial arts hold, putting on the pressure, coming closer and closer to making it snap...
"Wait! No!" cries Joe. "I'll confess! It wasn't Ben, it was Annabelle! She was my partner in crime!"
You freeze. "Annabelle?! But she's an old family friend of Jack and Holly..."
Joe shrugs, wincing in pain from the arm you broke. "Friendships can die."
"But WHY..."
"She said that Holly and Jack were too naive, letting just anyone into the castle. She said sooner or later they'd let someone in who'd fuck everything up and get us all killed. So she and I formulated a plan to get the others killed off one by one in unfortunate 'zombie accidents.' Once their numbers had been whittled down enough, we'd just shoot the rest. In fact, we were planning to do it right before they brought you in, but your arrival ruined our plans."
Your body is still shaking from the shock. "How can I believe you..."
"Annabelle was the only one checking up on me. If I was faking it, she'd have to be in on it too."
You nod slowly. "Then I'll go confront Annabelle. As for you..." You suddenly karate chop Joe in the neck, knocking him out. "I'll let Jack and Holly decide what to do with you."
You quickly inform Holly and Jack of the situation. Both of their mouths drop open in shock. Jack shakes his head. "If I didn't see Joe here out of bed, I wouldn't believe it."
"That bitch," growls Holly, clenching her fists and causing the muscles in her slender but powerful forearms to ripple. "After all those years, after all the trust we put in her...I'm going to confront Annabelle right now." She storms out of the room.
"You should go with her, Marina," says Jack. "I'll keep an eye on Joe."
By the time you catch up with Holly, she already has Annabelle in a chokehold. Though Annabelle is freakishly strong, Holly is just as powerful, and her fury makes Annabelle unable to escape.
"Marina, please!" Annabelle cries upon seeing you. "Stop her! I can help you guys! Please..."
