Tell him about the shipwreck

From Create Your Own Story

Kurt appears troubled by the tale of the mysterious destruction of your ship, but the matter of your memory loss makes him understandably suspicious.

"One moment, please," he murmurs, unrolling a sheet of parchment lying on his desk.

His eyes skim through the document, then come back to you. Quick as lightning, the priest draws a pistol from under his desk and points it straight at you.

"Take off your shirt," he commands. "I want to see your chest."

You could of course refuse to do it, or even attack the priest.