Take Candelas' cherry the old fashioned way

From Create Your Own Story

You get onto the bed and start getting onto Candelas. As you move over her, Miranda grabs for your cock, but you slap her hand away gently.

"Later, Miranda," you tell her.

You see Herculio pull out his cock as you position yourself over his sister. He just watches you as you spread her legs, stroking his cock hard. You realize that he's getting off on the idea of his sister getting fucked in front of him. That's why he volunteered her so fast.

You pull her legs farther apart as you have trouble getting the tip of your cock into her. She's still curiously passive, despite looking frightened. You start to push harder against her.

"Wait!" Miranda says, spitting a newly emptied cock out of her mouth. "I want to watch!"

The guy fucking Miranda shrugs, pulls out, then puts her on her hands and knees, facing you and Candelas before entering her again. Without a word, the guy pounding Katie does the same, although she seems less eager to watch, or even to be there at all.

Feeling your little sister's hungry eyes on you now, you feel yourself getting even hornier. You move forward into the young hispanic girl, taking your third virginity of the day. She gives a curiously muffled cry as she is taken, echoed by a loud moan from her brother just a few feet away.

"Fuck, man," Herculio gasps, still jacking his cock intensely. "Please tell me what it feels like."

You stop to savor the moment. "She's tight. I could barely get in. It's like she's trying to squeeze me out of her."

Your words make her brother moan more. Your slow movements make Candelas moan as well, although in a somehow more restrained way. She's quieter than both Miranda and Katie were, and not fighting at all like Katie did.

"That's it," Herculio urges. "Fuck that little angel."

Miranda keeps watching intently as you rape Herculio's little sister. Even Katie watched, wide-eyed, almost seeming to forget what is happening to her.

And now Candelas is no longer so quiet. She's moaning now, even though she still seems to be in pain. But pain and pleasure are very close.

"Oh, don't even think about pulling out, Josh," Herculio warns you. "You better fill my sister up." You hadn't planned on pulling out of her, and now you're afraid to see what Herculio would do to you if you did.

Then Candelas does finally scream, but it is more of lust than of fear or pain. Pent up emotion takes the form of a powerful orgasm in her young body. Her pussy squeezes painfully down on your cock, all but forcing you to blow your load into her.

"Fuck!" Herculio calls out. Then you see him shoot a load all over his sister's face and tits. She quivers again at the sensation, still cumming from your cock. You hear Miranda moan, and see her shaking as she crawls forward just a little, while still being fucked, and start licking Herculio's cum off of Candelas.

"You, too," the guy fucking Katie tells her, moving her forward without removing his cock from her. With far less enthusiasm than your sister, she also begins to clean Candelas up, although tears replace cum in some places.

You pull out of the little latina's freshly popped pussy, and step back to catch your breath. You wait to see what happens next.