Play the middle road: ask her to take her bra off without removing her top.
From Create Your Own Story
“Take your bra off without removing your top," you dare. She looks shocked for a second but then smiles in a sexy way and waits for Adam not to be looking.
As soon as his back is to you she unstraps her bra and pulls it off. She throws it to you and you sit on top of it. You both try to look like nothing happened as Adam turns around again. You whisper just loud enough for Kara to hear, “Wow, that was fast."
"Well it’s nothing!" she giggles quietly. "Almost every girl can do it. But tell me - why did you ask for me to remove just my bra and not my shirt?”
You pause for a moment, thinking of the appropriately 'half-depraved, half-surprising' response, and say “Because I'm sure you've had a hard week at school and you need to relax.” You start to massage her shoulders playfully, and she moans a bit.
As Adam gets off the phone, he asks, “What are you doing?"
“Massaging me because I had a hard week, obviously, if you'd listened to me earlier Adam!" Kara defends you.
Luckily, Adam laughs and says, “I was listening, I just didn’t care about your girly drama. That's what brothers do."
“At least your friend cares!" She looks up at you blissfully and you think I’m just like Adam, I don’t care, but nod in agreement as you continue massaging her. After a little bit, you pick up your game controller again and join Adam. Kara sits close to you and leans her body on you; you feel her nice firm breast on your arm.
When the doorbell rings, Adam pauses the game and says “Pizza’s here!” delightedly. As he stands up, he looks at you and Kara thoughtfully and says something you would never expect. "You two look like you’re a couple."
"Why would you say that?" you ask, trying to stay casual even though you've been on edge ever since Kara started being flirty with you in front of her brother.
“No reason. I've known you both practically my whole life, and if Kara was to date someone I guess I would rather it be you than anyone else," Adam blesses you, walking out the door and down the stairs.
What the hell. Adam sure is sneaky. He knows you don't date exclusively, and now he's planted the seed in Kara's head. You can't expect to fuck her meaninglessly anymore, which was probably his plan.
Do you say:
