Go with the pulling out method a.k.a the withdrawal method

From Create Your Own Story

Caught up in the excitement Jack forgets to withdrawal in time. Both you and Jack are unsure of whether your “solution” worked. You are scared because you do not want to get pregnant, but then a week later you get your period and you think the scare is over.

• The withdrawal method must have worked, continue using this method
• Use a condom from now on
• Getting pregnant is not something you are ready for right now, so use a condom and look into getting birth control