Drag the black-tailed mermaid down after the sinking Gem

From Create Your Own Story

You push the other two mermaids out of your way and ignore the fact that you're dragging the black-tailed mermaid along with you as you dive. You surprise yourself by getting your hand over the Water Gem. Just at that moment, your dick pops loose from the mermaid's grasping snatch. You sink rapidly, but you're breathing easily again. You land on a coral reef dotted with large holes leading into darkness.

The three mermaids dive towards you. It looks like they want to tear you apart.

Do you:

• Toss the Water Gem into your mouth
• Ask the mermaids which one wants your dick next
• Dive into a hole in the coral

Treasures Collected
The Water Gem