Keep him as your personal slave
From Create Your Own Story
You catch his cheek hard with the back of your hand, sending him sprawling into the mud. He looks back up at you, tears in his eyes, whimpering as a powerful feeling of raw sexuality overcomes you. "From now on, you will be my slave. You will do everything I tell you to do, when I tell you do it. Do you understand?" The young man seems to shocked to answer, but as you raise the back of you hand in warning he falls to his knees. "Yes! Yes of course!"
"Yes mistress!" you bellow.
"Yes mistress!" he rectifies, clasping his hands together, voice shrill. You can barely suppress a laugh. This is fun. "Good. Now… strip to your undergarments." As you watch him strip, shivering in the cold, morning air, you have a sudden realisation- the paladin business is bad. You're becoming a bandit! And a lot better one than these jokes. Your combat training and intellect should help you bring in the real money. "Guess we won't be needing your friends anymore," you state casually, strolling over the tied up group as you pull your hunting knife from your belt. You cast a look over your shoulder at your new slave, looking at you, horrified and cold. "Lighten up!" You cry as you cut the first one's throat. "At least you get out of this alive!"
It takes you a few minutes to finish up with business and back everything of note up. You hand two bags, yours and one of the bandits', to him to carry, each full of stuff. He is also allowed to wear a fur cloak to shelter him from the cold. Now that you have a bona fide slave, going into the village would be too risky. Plus it would help if the locals didn't see your face too much, especially if you're going to set up shop here. Where are you going to go?