Leave and go to Carly's house
From Create Your Own Story
After causing that bloodbath, you had this awkward urge to see Carly. Minutes after leaving Sam's house, you arrive at Carly's house. You knock several times but get no answer. You peer in through their peephole. It's mainly a blur but you can see two nude figures on the couch. You press your ear to the door and hear grunts and moans. Then you bang on the door nearly knocking it off the hinges. It took some time but Carly came and answered the door.