Because what he's saying is impossible

From Create Your Own Story

"Because that's impossible, and you're insane! Humans can't breed with horses, and even if they could, a centaur wouldn't fit! Now let me go!" you exclaim at the rancher.

He considers this a moment, and replies, "Sure, it's impossible normally, but that's why I performed a special ritual on my stud here. Don't worry, you're going to be a dam." At the astonished and terrified look on your face, he says, "I suppose there is something I can do to help with your second problem, though, but you might not like it."

You:

• agree to what he's going to do
• beg to have the foal removed