Let David fuck your ass
From Create Your Own Story
You've done anal several times before and actually quite enjoyed it once you'd understood the right techniques. You're worried that you're not able to satisfy both of them. You don't want this to end in disappointment so you take the bottle and lube your ass whilst Mark continues to fuck you. It's the second time you've had two fingers in your ass and a dick in your pussy in the last ten minutes. Different fingers. Different dick. You had never seen yourself as this kind of girl before but you're really enjoying being naughty.
You get off of Mark and onto all fours at the foot of the bed. David stands behind you and runs his hard dick between your buttocks, adding some more lube as he does so. Mark kneels in front of you but he's going to have to wait for now.
You tell David to stay completely still. You reach between your legs and aim his dick at your asshole, take several deep breaths to relax, and then push back against him.
Nothing happens. Is his girth too much? You've never had one that size in your ass before. But then it starts to penetrate you. You wince slightly and close your eyes as you feel your asshole opening. Then, suddenly, his tip is in. You gasp then everyone is silent for several seconds. Nobody knows whether you're going to continue, including yourself.
Once settled, you push back again. It feels like he's about 2ft into you at this point but in reality, it's only about half his cock! Encouraged by his groans, you start rocking back and forth, gradually taking more and more.
You open your eyes and see that Mark's losing his erection. You can't let that happen so you immediately take him in your mouth.
David holds your hips and takes control. Gently fucking you, he gradually gets faster and deeper. Concentrating on sucking Mark helps you ignore the discomfort, relax, and eventually start enjoying David's fat cock in your ass.
After a couple of minutes, Mark says, "I want you to ride me again. I was enjoying that so much."
"Mmm, of course," you agree. Your ass could do with a rest anyway.
You lean forward and David withdraws. "I'm not sucking you now it's been in there though!"
The three of you laugh as you get back on Mark. Anal's fun but you prefer cock in your pussy.
As Mark thrusts satisfyingly deep, you feel David pouring lube all over your butt. You turn and see him getting ready to put his cock in your ass.
You:
