The confident, black-haired one.
From Create Your Own Story
SMACK! The stick cracks the black-haired girl in the side of the head and she goes down, out cold. Now for the brunette...
She doesn't even scream. Turns out her shy looks hide some kind of martial arts nut. She leaps up when you swing for her, grabbing the stick as it passes and re-directing it into the ground. Then she gives you a sharp kick to the jaw that makes you crash back into the wall with your head spinning.